Pilot scenario questions: how to answer "what would you do"

Short answer: Scenario questions ("You smell smoke at cruise. What do you do?") test your priorities, not trivia. Answer in this order: fly the airplane, run the checklist or follow company procedure, bring in the crew and outside help (ATC, dispatch, cabin, maintenance), make a clear decision, then follow it through and report. Say it out loud as you would in the airplane.

Last checked November 1, 2026.

A 5-step method

  1. Aviate. Who's flying, and is the airplane under control? Say it: "The pilot flying keeps flying."
  2. Procedure. Name the checklist, QRH or company procedure you'd use. You don't need the exact steps for an airplane you don't fly.
  3. Crew and resources. Who else needs to know or help: the other pilot, the cabin, ATC, dispatch, maintenance, medical support on the ground?
  4. Decide. Make a clear call: continue, return, divert, delay, refuse. Give the reason in one sentence.
  5. Follow through. Brief the plan, tell the passengers if needed, and say what happens after (a report, a debrief).

FedEx is one airline that says its process includes "situational-based interviews". Most airlines don't publish their question types, so prepare for scenarios either way.

Worked example: engine fire just after V1

Example answer, written by us for a generic two-engine jet. Always follow your airline's procedures. Question: "You're the pilot flying. An engine fire warning goes off just after V1. Talk me through it."

"Past V1 we're committed to the takeoff, so I continue. I fly the airplane: rotate at VR, pitch for the engine-out climb speed, and keep it straight with rudder. Positive rate, gear up. We don't touch anything until we're at a safe altitude, except what our procedure allows earlier, and the captain or pilot monitoring confirms which engine before any memory items.

At the procedure's altitude we'd run the memory items and the engine fire checklist, confirming each switch together. I'd ask the pilot monitoring to declare an emergency with ATC, ask for vectors and tell the cabin crew what's happening and what we need from them.

Then we decide where to land. Usually that means returning to the departure airport if weather and runway allow, after checking landing performance at our weight. We brief the approach, tell the passengers and land. After the flight we'd write it up and debrief."

What makes it work: committed after V1, aviate first, no rushed switch-pulling, both pilots confirm the engine, every resource used, a clear decision.

13 scenarios to practice

From the Fourstripe question bank (written by us):

  • An engine fire warning goes off just after V1.
  • At 80 knots on the takeoff roll, the master caution comes on.
  • You smell smoke in the flight deck at cruise.
  • Cruising, a flight attendant calls: a passenger is unresponsive.
  • A passenger refuses to follow crew instructions and gets aggressive. The lead flight attendant calls you.
  • Destination weather drops below minimums and fuel is getting tight.
  • ATC gives you a heading that points you straight at a thunderstorm on your radar.
  • The captain is flying an approach. At 500 feet you're fast and high, and they keep going.
  • You're the first officer on a late-night leg. The captain is clearly exhausted and has made a few small mistakes.
  • On the morning of a trip you smell alcohol on your captain.
  • Before departure, the captain wants to go with a deferred item you're not sure is legal.
  • In the sim, you lose a hydraulic system on downwind. Handle it with your captain.
  • We're about to fly a single-engine ILS in the sim. Brief me as if I'm your captain.

What panels usually listen for

  • Priorities: fly first, then navigate, then communicate.
  • Procedure: the checklist, QRH and SOPs, said out loud.
  • Crew and communication: the other pilot, ATC, cabin and dispatch all brought in.
  • Decision: a clear call, followed through.

Common mistakes

  • Rushing to switches. Panels want to hear "fly the airplane" first.
  • Going it alone. A scenario answer with no crew in it fails the CRM test.
  • Being vague on the decision. "I'd evaluate the situation" isn't a decision. Say what you'd do and why.
  • Breaking the rules to be nice. In the alcohol or fatigue scenarios, the safe and legal answer comes first, handled with respect.

Practice this on Fourstripe. A panel captain gives you a scenario out loud, then changes it ("Now the other engine shows a caution"). You're scored on priorities, procedure, crew and decision. 7-day trial, then from $149 a week. Start a practice interview

Frequently asked questions

What is a scenario question in a pilot interview?

A hypothetical situation, such as an engine fire after V1 or a captain who smells of alcohol, where you explain what you would do. It tests priorities, procedure and CRM more than knowledge.

Is there a right answer to a pilot scenario question?

Usually there is a right order more than a right answer: fly the airplane, follow the checklist and company procedure, bring in the crew and outside help, make a clear decision and follow it through.

Should I give exact procedures for an airplane I don't fly?

No. Say what you'd do in general terms and that you'd follow the airline's checklist and QRH. Inventing a procedure for an airplane you don't fly is a common mistake.

Do airlines say they use scenario questions?

Some do. FedEx says its process includes 'situational-based interviews'. Most airlines don't describe their question types.

Sources

Related guides